Aller à l'en-tête Aller au menu principal Aller au contenu Aller au pied de page
Skip to main content
Ab Ab Ab A- A A+ Print
  • Français
  • English

UNIVERSITÉ PARIS-PANTHÉON-ASSAS

Home
FRENCH JOURNAL OF LEGAL POLICY
  • About
    • Presentation
    • Governance
    • Scientific Advisory Board
    • The Journal
      • Publication
      • Selection of contributions
  • Last Issue
  • Issues
  • Authors
  • Submit

Primary tabs

  • View(active tab)
  • Generate PDF
Accueil - Numero Revue - No. 1 - December 2023 - Challenging Textual Interpretation in Multilingual Legal Systems

Challenging Textual Interpretation in Multilingual Legal Systems

Challenging Textual Interpretation in Multilingual Legal Systems
Pascal Pichonnaz
06/12/2023
Cite this article

By presenting the Swiss approach to statutory interpretation, ie the pragmatic pluralism of methodologies, this paper underlines that this is a good way for the judge to take into account a basic principle: different cultures, different languages produce different texts. Since the same idea cannot be expressed in the same way in different languages, one cannot stick to the wording in order to find the common meaning of all these various wordings. More visible in multilingual legal regimes, this principle applies, however, also to monolingual systems. It is not possible to stick to a 'clear' wording without a proto-interpretation of such wording through which the judge weighs all the approaches in order to get to a solution that reflects the underlying normative values.

Notes de bas de pages

×

Pour citer l'article

Pascal PICHONNAZ, « Challenging Textual Interpretation in Multilingual Legal Systems », FRENCH JOURNAL OF LEGAL POLICY, No. 1 - December 2023, , .

Download article

Retrieve a PDF file of the online article

Download PDF

Table of contents

Table of contents

No. 1 - December 2023

Articles
Challenging Textual Interpretation in Multilingual Legal Systems
Pascal PICHONNAZ
Level Playing Field - The Meanings of a Discourse Justifying the Action of the European Union
Francesco MARTUCCI
Corporate Asset Locks: A Comparative and European Perspective
Florian MÖSLEIN Anne SANDERS
Is Payment a Blind Spot in the Development of Cryptocurrencies?
Marie BOUTRON-COLLINOT Anabel RIAÑO-SAAD
Taking EU Product Liability Law Seriously: How Can the Product Liability Directive Effectively Contribute to Consumer Protection?
Jean-Sébastien BORGHETTI
Book reviews
A Model of Doctrinal Pluralism?
Julie FERRERO
Identity as Self-Assertion. The Age of Rights and the Challenges of Postmodernity
Luca VESPIGNANI

Archives

No. 1 - December 2023

Suivez nous

Logo Footer Revue

 

 

  • About
  • List of issues
  • Authors
  • Last number
  • Submit
  • Command
  • Contact
  • HAL Panthéon-Assas Université
  • Bibliothèques de l'université
  • ENT
  • Sitemap
  • Legal mentions
  • Accessibility
FRENCH JOURNAL OF LEGAL POLICY